I should start by letting you know that Bennigan’s was one of my favorite local restaurants when it was still operating. There was very little I didn’t like about Bennigan’s. I would often eat there several times a week. I would occasionally go there by myself if I wanted to get away from everyone and just relax for a meal or to watch a game. I was really upset when Bennigan’s closed - especially about the numerous free meal tickets I had yet to cash in.
To be honest, I had heard a couple of things about Krieger’s that were not very flattering. I had heard the food was average, the wait to get served after you ordered was long, and some of the staff were not exactly overly-friendly. In the past these remarks would have been enough for me to avoid a restaurant. But since I started doing this column, how could I not go to a place where I have an opportunity to inform everyone about how lousy the food is, how long it takes to be served, and how rude the waiters and waitresses are?! I just had to go - and so I had lunch there today.
You have heard that famous line “the best laid plans of mice and men often go astray” - as did mine at lunch today. I went to Krieger’s already figuring out how to pan the place - and then upon arrival the following things happened: (1) we were seated immediately; (2) the hostess and the waitress were both very friendly; (3) the waitress was there immediately and got our drinks within a couple of minutes; (4) the waitress informed us of their specials and, upon learning it was my first time there, made recommendations as to what to order (a lost art in the service industry); (5) the food arrived within 10 minutes - and it was exceptionally good. Obviously this put a real kink in my plans.
At the waitresses suggestion, I had the steak sandwich (a special for the day) and fries. The fries were really good and, apparently, “endless” - more on that later. The steak sandwich was very good. I normally like A-1 steak sauce for my steak sandwiches, but this came with a side of horseradish sauce that decided to try before I drenched the steak in A-1. I am glad I am adventurous because the horseradish sauce was great - it was the perfect compliment for the steak and a nice balance to the ketchup I have to have for my fries.
My dining partner that day ordered the chicken parmesan. Of course I had to try some of it - which turned out not to be a problem because that was a huge serving of food. It was also as good as - if not better than - the chicken parmesan you get at more familiar chains (read “Olive Garden”).
The prices were about the same as Bennigan’s used to be - which means it was not exactly a cheap lunch even though we didn’t order any alcoholic drinks ($25.00 for the two of us, plus the tip). I think I may have found my Bennigan’s replacement.
Now for the other shoe, so to speak. Despite my pleasant surprise at the quality and speed of the food, and the pleasant and efficient service, there were three items I feel it necessary to point out. First, the supposedly “endless” fries are apparently only endless if you tell the staff you want more of them. The otherwise tremendous job done by the waitress was marred only by the fact that she never informed us the fries were endless nor did she ever ask if we wanted more of them. I am not sure if this was an error on her part or if Krieger’s trains them not to inform nor ask so as not to have to give away more fries than is necessary. I only learned of the “endlessness” of the fries as I was familiarizing myself with their menu just before we left - after we had already finished our meal.
Second, at Bennigan’s you could always play the trivia game they had available. I think the only place in the area with that game now is Buffalo Wild Wings (a review on there to come soon).
Finally, I think it takes more than televisions turned to different versions of ESPN and replica jerseys hanging on the wall to make a place a “sports bar.” It would be nice to find a place that has some real sports memorabilia to display - something to actually make people remember and think about the games of the past.
As those of you who have read this column in the past know, it is not beyond me to be really picky with my reviews - and I am sure my criticisms here rise to that level. To sum it up, Krieger’s is a welcome replacement for what was one of my favorite local restaurants. The food is excellent, the service we had was great (except for the fry thing). I can tell you that Krieger’s has joined Gabby’s on my rotation for lunch spots. On our grading scale of 1 to 10, I give the meal an 8. Except for the french fry travesty, it would have been a 9. I will also recommend it to anyone asking for a place to get a great meal, although not exactly an inexpensive one.
